When I signed online and logged in, it did not take long for me to realize what had happened. My fears had been realized; there were no remaining rooms for me to choose. Every room, every person, and everything had been settled, chosen, and completed.
What was I supposed to do?
As I sat on my bed, thinking about what had just happened and what my options were, I thought back on my conscious decision to choose housing with someone I had never met. I had attempted to find a roommate through the school’s online roommate-finder—eerily similar to a quasi-dating service—but, unfortunately, my attempts were to no avail. Similarly, summer orientation seemed as though it would be a proper (and more legitimate) place to befriend potential roommates, but again, I returned home with no success. Thus, I eventually accepted and acknowledged fate as my best option, planning to choose a roommate at random. At the time, I thought this to be a terrible mistake, having no further options for housing. However, I can happily acknowledge how wrong I was; waking up late that bright summer morning was by far one of the best mistakes I have ever made.
Fate is a philosophical concept I had never truly contemplated until I had spent several months away from home living at school. Being such an abstract idea, fate remains a difficult idea for me to fully understand. The word and its implications can be traced back to the Latin word Fatum, deriving from the verb meaning “to speak” (Bargdill, 206-207). While “destiny” is commonly used as a synonym for “fate,” Bollas’ philosophical work (1989) denotes the significant difference between the words. “Destiny” originates in the Latin word “destinare,” meaning “to fasten down, secure, or make firm,” (Bollas, 32). Bollas further states how destiny involves direction or a predetermined plan, linked to “actions” rather than words; “If fate emerges from the word of the gods, than destiny is a preordained path that man can fulfill” (Bolla, 32). The technical definitions and roots of the word “fate” can thus quickly become exceedingly theological, philosophical, and complicated.
A few months prior to online housing selection, I had made the incredibly difficult decision of selecting which college to attend. With this decision, I was fully aware of how different my life would be depending on the school I attended the following fall. At the time of housing selection, however, I was ignorant and oblivious to the weight this single decision would carry in my life from that point forward.
After I remained on my bed for a while after being denied housing selection, I walked downstairs, still contemplating my course of action from this point. I found my dad in his office, working on his computer. As I explained the situation to him, I could see anger and frustration rising in his eyes. He immediately picked up the phone and called the school, questioning them as politely as he could what happened and what my options were. They told him that the rooms were all simply occupied, and that I would have to re-select housing in a few days—in a forced triple. Neither me nor my father were too excited about this; not only were we assured by the college that there would not be forced triples the following year due to conscious efforts by the college to minimize overcrowding, but neither of us expected that I would be forced to do so.
I shook off the frustration that followed me for the rest of the day, and tried to think optimistically. This could work. I could make this work. It had to work.
A few days later, I awoke to the sound of my alarm buzzing annoyingly in my ear. Glancing to the clock after smacking it hard for waking me so early, I realized it was not even seven o’clock in the morning. This time, I was prepared. This time, I would be there when housing selection went live. At this point, I was determined to get this right. After all, I would be forced to live with these strangers for almost a year.
Refreshing the page every few seconds, my heart began to race as a cold sweat engulfed my body. I became increasingly fidgety, attempting not to consider how the decision I was about to make could possibly determine the difference between one life path and another. After a few page refreshes, I was enabled access to the web page, and quickly skimmed through the available housing. Clicking frantically, I read through housing profiles as quickly and efficiently as possible. Regrettably, I was very critical and judgmental while skimming through each profile— “Battlestar Galactica” nerd here, nudist enthusiasts there, lacrosse bros everywhere…but no one who seemed like a good match for me.
Finally, I found a room with two other people who seemed like a suitable match. Skimming through their profiles, they both seemed similar enough to me that I would at least get along with them. Making my decision official and final, I joined the room.
Over the next month, I made attempts to become friendly with my new roommates. Wanting to avoid any sort of problems, I was determined to establish a healthy relationship with them. I had no idea how close I would become with these individuals who, at the time, I considered to be strangers.
Almost a year later, I think back on the experience quite often. I have spent countless hours analyzing how it was possible for everything seemed to fall into place so smoothly in my transition from my home to college life. Every time I examine how everything and every relationship came to be, my mind always returns to, “it was fate.”
Fate initially seems like a simple concept to understand—that significant events, actions, and plans happen because they are “destined” to happen—but can swiftly become confusing when every factor or possibility comes to mind. What if I had awoken early enough to select housing? What if I had chosen another room to join? What if I had found a roommate prior to housing selection? Had any of these possibilities been a reality, my life today would most assuredly be completely different.
My greatest fear going into college was not the classes or course load—it was the daunting task of making new friends and starting my social life completely anew. Before leaving for school, I was terrified by all the horror stories I had been told about terrible roommate experiences. Being raised in a small town and being timid by nature, I had remained friends with the same group of people since early elementary school. To this day, the majority of my home friends are people that I have remained friends with since before I was a teenager. At home, I had developed relationships that were well-established; however, none of these were as close to some I have now.
Since starting my college life away from home, I have established some of the best friends I have ever had over the course of my entire life. I feel closer to several individuals in college than I have ever felt when I lived at home. According to a study conducted by Brown University, almost half of freshmen college students are “extremely satisfied” with their roommates (Fazzalaro, par. 1). Because of this, in addition to my personal experiences, my fears of terrible roommates are now a figment of the past. Living with two other people has provided an experience to make unique connections in a manner that I have never faced in my nearly twenty years alive. Likewise, I consider myself incredibly lucky for blindly choosing to room with a person who would become not only my best friend at school, but be one of the most interesting people I have ever had the pleasure to meet. Building such close relationships with both my roommates yielded opportunities to meet other people with whom I am now also extremely close. Furthermore, because of these branching connections and tight-knit relationships, I was also able to find a girl with whom I can share a mutual quirkiness and love unconditionally.
Incredibly, all of this was possible as a result of my housing selection. From my relationships, memories, class selections, purchases—everything made possible because of who I chose to room with. Because of this truly extraordinary (and yet, strangely ordinary) circumstance, I have been enabled to view my life—and others’—from a new perspective. I have found that sometimes, things are better left up to chance. Sometimes, decisions are made and events happen because they are meant to happen that way—for the better or worse, no matter the stakes. Sometimes, I realize, some things are simply the result to fate’s incredible invisible influence.
Works Cited
Bargdill, Richard W. “Fate and Destiny: Some Historical Distinctions Between the Concepts.” Saint Francis University. 206-207. February 2007. Web. 19 April 2011.
Bollas, C. “Forces of destiny: Psychoanalysis and human destiny.” Northvale NJ: Jason Aronson. 1989. Web. 19 April 2011.
Fazzalaro, Kristina. “Just the two of us: most satisfied with freshmen roommate.” The Brown Daily Herald, Brown University. 16 November, 2010. Web. April 19, 2011.
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteI really liked the relevance of your paper, the entire class can relate to the anxiety of living with strangers/roommates in college. I liked the imagery of waking up in the morning with a lazy attitude, until you remember something was due. Everyone can relate to that feeling.
In the 6th paragraph when you were stating your research about fate and destiny, I think you could cut it down a little. Since you are giving definitions of words like destiny and fate, you can paraphrase that and avoid clunky quotation marks. Also remember that in MLA format we don’t use a comma after the authors’ name. In the paragraph that begins with “My greatest fear” (par.16) two of your sentences seem redundant. You talk about being raised in a small town and knowing the same people, and then again about people you knew before you were a teenager. Try to combine these sentences because it’s the same idea.
Overall great draft! Good luck with revisions!
-Christina
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteIt was refreshing to read up on a story that wasn't entirely controversial or serious. That being said it was a nice story, happy ending and all. It was relevant and interesting, and quite personal. All of which is impressive. Don't go so heavy on defining fate and destiny because it really is just serving as more of a distraction. I understand it's hard to incorporate research for this. I honestly think if you use less the story will serve it's purpose well.
Good luck with revisions!
-Mark Melchior
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteNice job on your first draft. I liked how you made great use of a small-scale story. You made a story that you can simply tell people in a few words into a narrative argument about fate, and I enjoyed that.
Until the very end, I felt like I was waiting to know something about your relationship with your roommates, and even after you said one is your best friend, I still feel like that could be expanded upon. After all, your roommates are a major part of your essay.
I personally think your research on fate and destiny was well-suited for this essay. It remained a narrative, but you threw in some interesting factual information. I think you should keep that in the narrative. Maybe just eliminate a few words to make it seem less dictionary-like.
Nice job. good luck on your revision.
- Greg
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteYou did a really nice job in creating a narrative story. Especially in the first paragraph where you produced a picture that was really easy to view. Even your sentence structure and tone went along with the feelings you had when you were picking housing.
I also liked your topic because it was very relatable. I too had a ton of trouble with picking housing. I was able to relate to your frustration and your story.
Here are a few things to work on:
Just a little note, in the 6th paragraph, you should incorporate Bolas more. While I was reading, I wanted to know who he was and why he was credible for your research.
I felt that throughout your paper, your argument part was not until the very end. Most of your paper was filled with the narrative of your actual process of picking housing, but the most important part that you are trying to convey is about fate and how you became very good friends with your roommates. With that said, you should probably cut down a lot on the actual process and add a lot more about the friendship.
I understood as I was reading that fate brought you to being in their room and therefore made you friends, but it would be an even more interesting story if you talked more about your friendship. Maybe you can add something about how close you have become.
You could also touch on the points that Bolas made more. I feel like the definition of fate was placed randomly within your paper. You could incorporate what he said throughout your argument. Try to tie it in to make it flow more.
You could also go into a greater discussion about fate more. If fate is your main point in your argument, as a reader, I would like to see more of your thoughts on it. For example, in the last two paragraphs from your conclusion, you should add the concept of fate into them.
Good luck on your revision and really great job!
- Joni Fromer
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteYour paper was SO refreshing to read and so, so relatable. I am actually transferring schools after this year ( :[ ) and all of the same fears and anxieties keep coming back now. But your paper was a nice reminder of what I keep trying to tell myself - if Ithaca was meant to work out for me, it would have.
I thought that the spin you took on this story was really interesting - there are so many arguments you could talk about that relate to the college process/housing decisions/roommate issues/ etc. and fate was not the first thing I would think of, so this was really interesting to read.
I think that it was really successful how you talked about different thoughts and theories as well as the history behind the meaning of fate. It spiced up your story quite a bit so good job!
Your language is great and your writing flows very well. The imagery you use is fantastic and this is a very quick and easy read.
When you are revising this, I would try and think of how somebody might argue this however. It definitely holds relevance today and we can all relate to it SO well, but I think that many people might not find anything to argue with it. For example, in my case, I had an amazing lottery number for housing of 26 and woke up 30 minutes early while I was on vacation to make sure I got housing. I didn't have a roommate yet, etc. Things with my room mate and I have worked out fine, but we aren't very close, and I've realized that my room mate directly influences and affects my social life. My social life was fine this year but my lack of forming good, close friendships contributed to my unhappiness at Ithaca this year. If none of that had happened, maybe I would love it here. It's all fate, whether the outcome is positive or negative. My point here is just to make sure that people could argue the opposite of what you are saying.
Over all this essay is great so far. Good luck with the revisions!
-Meredith
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your first draft of your narrative. Every single one of us can relate because we went through the same experience. I thought your writing was very fluid and you seemed to have a plan on how to guide the essay.
To be quite honest, I thought the whole idea of fate was a bit cliche. At the end you talked about growing up and your friendships from home. I thought you could turn the essay around and have your message be to stay open to new experiences and friendships. Other than that, I thought it was great. Good luck on your revisions!
Greg Bloom
Hey,
ReplyDeleteYou chose a rather bold topic of discussing "fate", so kudos for that. The topic of fate is rather abstract, while you experiences of choosing roommates can reflect part of it...the argument is assumptive and I'm not quite sure how effective that is in establishing a particular claim.
I think everyone in teh class can relate to your experience since we are all here in college and have gone through the same process. You have good storytelling skills, and great use of sensory language especially where you mentioned, "my heart began to race as a cold sweat engulfed my body...". I'm actually looking forward to the discussion of your paper in class, as I am not sure as to what advice to give to you at this point.
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteI was really impressed reading your first draft. You have great story-telling skills and diction. I like how you connected such an abstract idea with something so extremely common and relatable.
I think that since you really stress on the idea of your anxiety of meeting your roommates and how the relationships would play out, you should talk about your first impression of them on move-in day; the first time you meet is really important ( I still remember the exact conversations I had with my roommates the first time we met)
I also feel like the paragraph starting with "a few months prior" is out of place. After that paragraph, you continue your story about getting housing. I think you should delay the paragraph about choosing IC until later so you can emphasize the narrative of matching up with roommates as a true example of fate and then back it up with the paragraph about the bigger decision of choosing which college to go to. Just a thought.
Great work, I really enjoyed reading your paper. Good luck with your revision
~Molly
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEthan,
ReplyDeleteVery good first draft! You skillfully told this story and the story was relatable and interesting!
Here are some good things about your essay:
- The inserts of humor and the use of reciting your actual thoughts helped us easily relate and understand what you was saying
- The dialog made a vivid image for the reader
- Good research and the sources really support what you are saying
Things to work on:
- Making sure you have a clear message and point. I'm not sure what you are arguing
- Expand on your sources; who is Bollas and why should we listen to him?
- Work on the chronological time of each event. Perhaps have the "few months prior section" nearer the beginning of the essay
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteGreat job on the first draft of your Narrative Argument. I really enjoyed reading it. I think you picked a great topic for this paper. I also went through the same difficult task of housing last semester and couldn’t find a room either, so I know how stressful that was. I think you did a great job in the narrative aspect of this paper, you told the story very well and incorporated many details to make sure that your reader was aware of how you were feeling (ex. The anxiety that you had).
I like how you were willing to accept fate and realized that by allowing fate to happen , it was the best decision of your life. I liked how you viewed your moment of great anxiety turned out to be one of the best things in your life because you were able to see all the good that came out of it.
In par. 14, I liked how you added all the different questions and different scenarios, ex: “What if I had awoken early enough to select housing? What if I had chosen another room to join? What if I had found a roommate prior to housing selection? Had any of these possibilities been a reality, my life today would most assuredly be completely different.” I think this allowed the reader to get inside your mind, and it was very effective.
Things to work on:
I liked your paragraph about fate and the research you used, but I think that you could incorporate more about fate in your paper. Maybe add a quote from someone who talked about fate and what it means to them. I think this would be good because it will provide an outside voice and add to your paper.
You stated that you are so happy that things turned out they way they did because you get along with your roommates and met so many great people, but I believe you should state perhaps a specific example of what you guys have in common that make you so happy. Don’t be so general.
I think you did a great job with your rough draft and on your way to a great paper. Good luck with your revisions!
-Becca Moran
-Ethan
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your essay! It was refreshing to read because although it was a topic we can all relate to, its not something that you would expect to read for an assignment of this nature. Your voice was really strong and not only did you grab my attention with your first paragraph but you kept it throughout. I enjoyed the fact that you took a simple yet defining moment for any freshman and interwove the idea of fate. It seemed like their was an even ratio between the narrative portion of your essay and the research part but, I would have liked to hear more about your relationship with your roommates. You build it up throughout the essay and talk about fate and then I feel like you leave the reader guessing.
Great draft! and good luck!
-chloe
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteI think you did a really good job on your first draft. I like the introduction, in that all of your descriptive and sensory details described a good picture in my head of what was going on. I also liked how you picked a simple topic that all of us can relate to in class.
What I really missed out on in this paper was the relationship and experiences you had with your roommates. Maybe throw in some examples of what you guys do together and what makes the relationship work so well. Also, maybe state your claim a little earlier because until I was unsure if the argument was believing in fate or that even strangers can end up making great friendships.
Overall, great job and good luck on your revisions.
Jake
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteYour paper was a very enjoyable read, especially since I had the same experience (except the sleeping til noon part. I actually got up at 7 to find that there were no rooms). Anyways, I think you told your story really well, and your topic is interesting and relatable to everyone in college.
Some things I would change would be to maybe find another person with a similar experience to increase your credibility, or even just a story about fate from any situation. Also, you were talking about your decision to come to Ithaca, then you never really finished the story with that. How did it tie into the whole "fate" idea. Also, show us how well you get along with your roommates with a story or something, just so readers really understand.
Lastly, the statistic from Brown could be really great, but were the roommates randomly assigned, or did they choose them? If they were random, this would be perfect, but if not then I feel like maybe you should find something else to use instead.
Overall, great paper. It was a really good read.
Lindsay
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your paper, it was really lighthearted yet at the same time everyone can relate to your feelings.you had some great details that really brought the paper alive, without bogging it down.
I think you could work on bringing your claim out earlier in the paper, and clarify a little bit what your claim is.
overall, great job and good luck with revisions.
Zane
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteGreat first draft! I loved how you used a personal experience that I'm sure everyone in the class can relate to. Every nervous detail you described seemed to match my own on the housing selection day. You have great attention to detail, that I appreciate fully. I loved your humor when describing your various choices. The essay was light but meaningful and I enjoyed reading it. You transition well from paragraph to paragraph and overall the essay flowed nicely.
With that said, this is a hard topic to research. I found that while the sixth paragraph was interesting and a good take on the topic, it was incorporated awkwardly and could possibly be summarized better. I also would have liked to see more sources on my the specific college roommate experience. I understand its hard, but try and find a strong source you can call on.
Maybe it would be interesting to have a quote from your roommates on the situation as well? (Obviously that would not be used as a source, but it still makes the essay even more credible).
Overall, just check for grammatical errors and redundant phrases.
Ultimately, great job I enjoyed reading it very much and good luck on your revision!
Molly Schneider
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteWell done on your paper! I found it really interesting to read, being that most of us can relate to that exact scenario. Your use of detail and action was very beneficial to your paper and I commend you on that. I also enjoyed your witty comments that were scattered throughout the story.
I thought your definition of fate was very interesting, but I am not sure how well it worked with the fluidity of the paper.
I noticed that you used the exploratory approach to reach your claim, and I totally approve of that. I think that you might want to hint at the claim earlier in the paper to keep your audience engaged.
I suggest doing a quick once over to check for problems with grammar. Reading the paper outloud usually helps me.
Good luck on revising!
Elizabeth Rubel
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteReally good choice of topc. I think everyone in the class can relate to the roomate selection process. I know mine was pretty hectic bu everythings seems to work its way out, just like you explained.
I know it was had to find sources for a topic like yours, mine was too, but try t find so sources that really help get your claim across.
Good luck,
-Dan Sheldon
Ethan,
ReplyDeleteYou wrote about the feelings I think all of us had coming into college and it was really fun to read your essay. In a way it brought me back to the summer when so much was up in the air and it was cool. That's a tribute to how well written your essay was so great job.
Not too much to work on, maybe another source but it's got to be difficult for something like this so it's not something to harp on.
Good luck with revisions.
-Brendan